Despite the ongoing COVID-19 health crisis, TCZ Law remains open and dedicated to providing an outstanding service to all clients. While you may have previously preferred to deliver your information and meet with us in-person at our office, we recommend other alternatives, such as scheduling a phone call or video conference to substitute for face-to-face meetings, and emailing us your personal information at your convenience.

Child Protection

Child Protection in Family Law in Canada is an area that is concerned with ensuring that children are safe, well cared for, and protected from abuse or neglect.  We will explore the process of child protection, including the legal framework, the roles of various parties involved, and the steps taken to protect the child.

Background of Child protection law

Child Protection Law is a legal framework that protects children from abuse, neglect, and other forms of harm. The law is designed to ensure that the best interests of the child are always put first and that their safety and wellbeing are paramount.

The roots of child protection in Ontario can be traced back to the late 19th century when child welfare became a public concern. At that time, children who were orphaned or abandoned were often placed in institutions, and there were few laws to protect them from abuse or neglect.

In the early 20th century, the Ontario government began to take a more active role in child welfare, and in 1912, it passed the first child protection law, known as the Children’s Protection Act. The Act established a system of child welfare agencies, known as Children’s Aid Societies (CAS), which were responsible for investigating allegations of abuse and neglect and providing services to families in need.

Over time, the child protection system has evolved, and there have been numerous legislative changes to better protect children and families. In 1984, the Child and Family Services Act (CFSA) replaced the Children’s Protection Act, and it remains the primary legislation governing child protection today.

Under the CFSA, CASs have the power to investigate allegations of abuse or neglect and take steps to protect children from harm, including removing them from their homes if necessary. The Act also recognizes the importance of keeping families together and requires that services be provided to families in order to help them address any issues that may be putting their children at risk.

The process of Child Protection application

When a child is at risk of harm or in need of protection, anyone can apply to the court for a child protection order under the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017 in Ontario. The process of applying for a child protection order involves several steps.

Step 1: Contacting the Children’s Aid Society

The first step in the child protection application process is contacting the Children’s Aid Society (CAS) in your area. The CAS is responsible for investigating allegations of child abuse and neglect and providing services to families in need of support. If the CAS determines that a child is in need of protection, it may initiate court proceedings or work with the family to develop a plan to address the child’s needs.

Step 2: Filing a Child Protection Application

If the CAS determines that court intervention is necessary, it will file a child protection application with the court. The application will include information about the child’s situation, the reasons why the child is in need of protection, and the steps that the CAS has taken to address the situation.

Step 3: First Court Appearance

Once the application has been filed, the court will schedule a first appearance. At the first appearance, the judge will review the application and determine whether there is enough evidence to support the need for a child protection order. The judge may also make temporary orders to ensure the child’s safety while the case is ongoing.

Step 4: Disclosure and Case Conference

After the first appearance, the parties to the case will exchange disclosure, which includes relevant documents and information related to the case. The parties will then attend a case conference, where they will discuss the issues in the case and attempt to reach an agreement. If an agreement is reached, the case may be resolved without the need for a trial.

Step 5: Trial

If an agreement is not reached, the case will proceed to trial. At trial, the judge will hear evidence from the parties and make a decision based on the best interests of the child. If the judge determines that the child is in need of protection, he or she may make a child protection order, which may include placing the child in the care of a relative, foster parent, or other caregiver.

In conclusion, the child protection application process involves several steps, including contacting the CAS, filing a child protection application, attending court appearances, exchanging disclosure, attending a case conference, and, if necessary, going to trial. The process can be complex and emotionally challenging for families, but it is designed to ensure that children who are in need of protection are kept safe and provided with the support they require.

The rights of the child

In Ontario, the child protection system is designed to protect the rights and best interests of children who are in need of protection. The law recognizes that children have fundamental rights that must be upheld, even in cases where they may be in conflict with the interests of their parents or caregivers. Here are some of the key rights of the child in child protection cases:

1. The right to be heard: Children have the right to express their views and have them taken into account in all matters that affect them, including child protection proceedings. The views of the child must be given serious consideration, taking into account their age and maturity.

2. The right to safety and protection: Children have the right to be protected from all forms of abuse, neglect, and harm. This includes physical, emotional, and sexual abuse, as well as neglect and other forms of harm.

3. The right to stability and continuity: Children have the right to stability and continuity in their lives, including their living arrangements, education, and relationships with family members and caregivers.

4. The right to cultural identity: Children have the right to maintain their cultural identity, including their language, religion, and customs. This is particularly important for Indigenous children, who have the right to maintain their connection to their Indigenous heritage and community.

5. The right to privacy: Children have the right to privacy, including the right to have their personal information kept confidential and not disclosed to unauthorized individuals or organizations.

6. The right to access services and support: Children have the right to access services and support that are necessary for their physical, emotional, and mental well-being. This includes health care, education, and social services.

In child protection cases, the rights of the child must be the primary consideration of the court and all parties involved. The child’s welfare and best interests must be the focus of any decisions that are made, and the child’s voice and perspective must be given serious consideration. Ultimately, the goal of the child protection system is to ensure that children who are in need of protection are kept safe, supported, and given the opportunity to thrive

Priority of child protection proceeding over custody disputes

The well-being and protection of children is of the utmost importance in family law proceedings. This is reflected in the legal principle that child protection proceedings take priority over custody disputes.

Child protection proceedings involve cases where the Children’s Aid Society (CAS) has taken steps to protect a child from harm or potential harm, such as neglect or abuse. CAS may remove a child from their home and place them in temporary care, or seek an order from the court to protect the child’s safety.

On the other hand, custody disputes involve parents or guardians seeking a court order to determine who will have legal custody of a child or children, including where they will live and who will make important decisions regarding their upbringing.

When a child protection proceeding and a custody dispute are taking place at the same time, the priority is given to the child protection proceeding. The reason for this is that child protection proceedings involve the immediate safety and well-being of the child, whereas custody disputes are typically more long-term and can be resolved at a later date.

If a judge determines that a child’s safety is at risk, they may make orders for the child’s protection, including removing the child from the home or placing restrictions on the actions of the parents or guardians. These orders are made to ensure that the child is safe and protected, regardless of the outcome of any custody dispute.

It’s important to note that the priority of child protection proceedings over custody disputes does not mean that custody disputes are not important. However, in cases where a child’s safety is at risk, it’s necessary to address the child protection issues first and foremost.

In some cases, child protection proceedings and custody disputes may be closely linked. For example, if a parent has been accused of abuse or neglect, their ability to have custody of their child may be called into question. In these situations, the court will still prioritize the child protection proceedings to ensure that the child is safe, but will also consider the custody dispute as it relates to the child’s best interests.

In summary, child protection proceedings take priority over custody disputes when they are happening concurrently. This is because the safety and well-being of the child is paramount and needs to be addressed before any custody disputes can be resolved.

If you have any questions about child protection, you are welcomed to get in touch with our TCZ Lawyer Eric Zhao who can provide guidance and ensure that your interests are protected.

Family Lawyer Toronto

Legal Framework

The legal framework for child protection in family law in Canada is governed by federal and provincial legislation. The federal government is responsible for the criminal law aspects of child protection, such as child abuse and neglect, while the provincial governments are responsible for the civil law aspects, such as child welfare and protection.

At the provincial level, child protection is governed by child welfare legislation, which varies from province to province. For example, child protection is governed by the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, while in British Columbia, it is governed by the Child, Family and Community Service Act.

Roles of Various Parties

In cases involving child protection in Canada, several parties are involved, including child protection agencies, the courts, the child’s parents or guardians, family law firm and other relevant parties. 

Child Protection Agencies: In children’s law reform act, child protection agencies are responsible for investigating and responding to allegations of child abuse or neglect.

Parents or Guardians: The parents or guardians of the child are also involved in the child protection process. They have the right to participate in court proceedings and to provide evidence regarding their ability to care for the child.

Steps in the Child Protection Process

Child protection is an ongoing topic, with the welfare of children being of paramount importance. In rare cases, child protection matters may even be brought before the Supreme Court of Canada. It is essential to seek legal advice and representation from lawyers who can provide guidance and support in navigating legal issues. 

The child protection process in Canada typically involves several steps, including the following:

  • Temporary removal of the child from their home may occur if the child protection agency believes that the child is at risk of harm. The child may be placed in the care of a relative, a foster family, or a group home while the investigation continues. This is done on a temporary basis and in the best interests of the child.
  • If the court determines that the child should remain in care, the child protection agency will work with the child’s parents or family lawyers to develop a plan of care. This may involve counseling, parenting classes, or other services aimed at helping the parents or guardians provide a safe and supportive home for the child.

Parents and guardians who have been accused of child abuse or neglect must take such allegations seriously and respond promptly. They must cooperate with child protection authorities and seek legal advice to protect their rights and interests. In cases where a child has been removed from their home, parents and guardians must take the necessary steps to demonstrate that they can provide a safe and nurturing environment for their child. While child protection can be a difficult process for families, the ultimate goal is to ensure the safety and wellbeing of children, and this should remain the focus throughout the proceedings.